ICFP is particularly useful in a multi-academy trust when every academy works from a consistent planning model, central costs are represented fairly, and trust leaders can examine both the consolidated position and each school's context. A single headline benchmark cannot do that job.
The Department for Education's ICFP guidance says trusts can manage the process across their schools and that internal comparison is easier when schools use the same model trust-wide. Consistency should apply to definitions and assumptions; it should not erase valid differences between academies.
Represent central services consistently
A central charge may fund finance, HR, estates, leadership or school-improvement staff. In statutory returns, much of that charge can appear as non-staff expenditure at school level even though it pays for people serving those schools. Looking only at the academy's local staffing and non-staffing percentages can therefore distort the picture.
A trust should agree a documented basis for allocating central income and costs in its management analysis. Pupil numbers may be appropriate for some services; transaction volumes, floor area or direct usage may be more meaningful for others. The purpose is not to manufacture identical metrics. It is to make like-for-like discussion possible and ensure the consolidated totals still reconcile.
Worked example: comparing two allocation methods
This is an illustrative example, not a recommended allocation policy.
A trust has £600,000 of central staffing cost across six academies. A simple pupil-number allocation assigns £90,000 to Academy A. The trust then tests a service-based allocation and assigns £72,000 because that academy buys fewer central services directly.
Under both versions, leaders check that the six school allocations total £600,000. They then review how the different basis changes Academy A's staffing and non-staffing metrics, whether the method reflects the service actually received, and whether it is stable enough to use in future planning rounds. Trustees can see the sensitivity rather than mistaking one allocation convention for an objective measure of efficiency.
Set a common method and retain local context
Trust-wide ICFP works best when the trust agrees:
- common data definitions and a planning timetable;
- shared assumptions where the underlying exposure is genuinely shared;
- a transparent treatment of central services and inter-school adjustments;
- a small set of scenarios that can be compared across the trust; and
- a record of local factors such as SEND provision, building constraints, growth or falling rolls.
Ranges and thresholds are conversation starters. A trust may choose a different contextual range for a deliberate operating model, but should document why, examine pupil and workload impact, and test whether the position remains affordable.
Our overview of ICFP for multi-academy trusts covers trust-wide workflow and governance. You can also request a demonstration to discuss how organisation-level and school-level analysis fit together.