ICFP School

From the notebook

ICFP vs Benchmarking

Benchmarking describes a comparative position; ICFP connects curriculum, staffing and finance assumptions to test whether future plans are workable and affordable.

Benchmarking and ICFP answer different questions. Benchmarking helps a school understand how a cost or ratio compares with other schools or previous periods. ICFP uses comparative evidence alongside pupil, curriculum, staffing and financial assumptions to test whether a future plan is workable and affordable.

Neither process should produce an automatic target. The Department for Education's ICFP guidance says metrics should be used with school context and other sources of information, and recommends modelling more than one future scenario.

What benchmarking can tell you

Benchmarking can show that a value is materially different from a relevant comparison group. That is useful because it directs attention. The next questions are whether the data and comparator are suitable, why the difference exists, what impact the spending has and whether it is affordable.

Historical comparisons also have timing limits. They describe the period reported and may not reflect a new pupil forecast, pay assumption, staffing restructure or curriculum model. This does not make them obsolete; it defines how they should be used.

What ICFP adds

ICFP connects variables that would otherwise be discussed separately. Depending on the phase and planning question, these can include pupil-teacher ratio, teacher contact ratio, average teacher cost, class size, leadership cost, curriculum-support cost and available funding.

The connection matters because the same headline cost can have different causes. A high teaching-cost percentage could arise from low pupil numbers, a particular curriculum offer, staffing structure, average salary or a combination of factors. Scenario modelling helps the team test those explanations and their consequences.

Worked example: the same benchmark, two decisions

This example is illustrative and uses invented figures.

Two schools each find that teaching costs are 2 percentage points above the median for their selected comparison group.

School A forecasts rising pupil numbers. Its scenario shows that planned classes fill over two years and the teaching-cost percentage moves closer to the comparator while the curriculum remains affordable. School B forecasts falling rolls. Keeping the same staffing structure widens its illustrative deficit to £140,000 in year three.

The benchmark raises the same question in both schools. ICFP produces different planning conversations because the forecasts, curriculum and financial consequences differ. School A may decide to monitor its plan; School B may need to test the timing and educational effects of structural changes.

A practical sequence

  1. Validate the underlying finance, staffing and pupil data.
  2. Select relevant comparison groups and note their limitations.
  3. Identify material differences, without treating the median or range as a target.
  4. Explain the school context and test the likely causes through connected metrics.
  5. Model at least two credible future scenarios.
  6. Record the educational, workload and financial implications for leaders and governors.
  7. Review the model when pupil, funding or staffing assumptions change.

For the wider decision process, read our guide to choosing ICFP software and why ICFP matters when setting a budget.

Source