ICFP should be a central part of budget setting because it connects the numbers in a forecast to the curriculum, staffing and pupil assumptions that create them. It turns the budget from a test of whether totals balance into a structured discussion about what the school plans to provide, what that plan will cost and how it will adapt if assumptions change.
The Department for Education's ICFP guidance recommends using ICFP within normal planning activity, looking three years ahead, modelling more than one scenario and reviewing plans when information changes. It also stresses that curriculum, finance and governance leaders should be involved.
Budget assumptions are uncertain
Pay awards, pupil numbers, funding, inflation and staffing changes are forecasts rather than facts. Good budget setting makes the uncertainty visible. For each material assumption, record its source, the date it was agreed, who owns it and which scenario tests the risk if it proves wrong.
ICFP then shows how those assumptions interact. A pupil-number change affects income, but may also change the affordable staffing requirement and the way a curriculum can be organised. A percentage change in pay affects different staffing models by different amounts.
Worked example: test the plan before approving it
This example is illustrative. Its figures are invented and are not budget assumptions for a real school.
A school begins with an illustrative three-year forecast of a £40,000 surplus, followed by deficits of £70,000 and £160,000. The base case assumes stable pupil numbers and the existing staffing model.
Leaders add a downside scenario with ten fewer pupils from year two, then a response scenario in which a vacant post is reviewed before recruitment. They compare the effect on income, staffing cost, class organisation, curriculum access, workload and reserves. The model may show that one action narrows the gap, but that does not make the action educationally acceptable or sufficient on its own.
The governing body now has a more useful decision: which risks can be tolerated, which mitigations are credible, when a trigger should prompt action and how the chosen plan supports pupils.
Metrics are prompts, not grades
RAG ratings and comparator ranges can help leaders find the questions that deserve attention. Green does not mean universally good, and red does not mean universally bad. A metric outside a range may reflect a deliberate and effective choice, or it may expose a plan that is no longer affordable. The team must examine context, impact and alternatives.
A sound budget-setting discussion asks:
- What educational provision are we trying to protect or change?
- Which assumptions have the greatest effect on the three-year position?
- Where does our deployment differ from relevant comparators, and why?
- What evidence do we have about the impact of material spending choices?
- Which alternative scenarios are credible, and what are their consequences?
- What will trigger a review during the year?
Make it a recurring planning cycle
ICFP is most useful before the budget is fixed and then at agreed review points. Update the model when pupil forecasts, funding information or staffing assumptions change. Keep a record of decisions so governors and trustees can see why the selected scenario remains appropriate.
To continue, compare ICFP with benchmarking, review ICFP for primary schools, or request a demonstration of scenario planning in ICFP.school.